Leadership in the AI Era: From Augmented Teams to Superhumans

Author

Charlene Li
October 13, 2025

Picture this: Your team member knows more about AI than you do. They're working faster, producing better results, and pushing boundaries you didn't even know existed.

Does that make you feel threatened, or excited?

If you're feeling a bit of both, you're not alone—and you're exactly where you need to be.

I've been fascinated lately by how AI isn't just changing what we do as leaders. It's fundamentally reshaping how we lead. And I want to share what I'm discovering as I finish the book “Winning with AI” I’ve been writing with Katia Walsh on this very topic.

The Three Core Responsibilities of Leadership (And How AI Transforms Each One)

Leaders have always had three fundamental jobs:

  1. Understand the situation.

  2. Decide on a clear path forward.

  3. Communicate direction and build relationships.

These responsibilities haven't changed across thousands of years of leadership. What has changed is our capacity to execute them.

Think of it as Leadership 2.0. This upgrade enhances what's possible in three specific ways:

🔭 Expanded Radar: You can see more of what matters.
AI helps you detect trends, process unstructured data, and spot signals you'd otherwise miss. Once you share those insights with your teams, it's not just you who benefits from better intelligence—it's your entire organization.

🏃 Accelerated Reflexes: You can respond faster and smarter, in real time.
AI enables you to analyze multiple options, understand risks, run scenarios, and model impacts before committing. Decision-making becomes more transparent, and multiple people can participate in ways that were never possible before.

🚀 Extended Reach: Your communication impact scales exponentially.
You can understand what different audiences need, adjust your message and tone in the moment, and communicate personally and consistently at scale.

This is why AI fluency is no longer optional for leaders. The potential to transform leadership efficiency, effectiveness, and impact is massive.

Two New Leadership Challenges You Can't Ignore

AI offers countless opportunities, but it also creates new challenges. Two in particular keep coming up.

Challenge #1: Leading AI-Augmented Teams

Expertise reversal is real. When your team knows how to use AI better than you do, it can feel threatening. Wise leaders have always surrounded themselves with people smarter than they are. The difference now is that AI widens that gap at lightning speed.

Your high-performing, AI-fluent employees are also at risk of leaving. Research shows there's an $18,000 premium for AI-fluent workers. If their productivity and impact aren't recognized or rewarded, they'll find organizations that will appreciate them.

The reality is that there will be fluency gaps within teams. Some people will jump in, others will resist. You'll need to manage those tensions while closing the gaps and potentially redesigning who does what work.

Challenge #2: Managing Autonomous Systems

Agentic AI is coming. The question isn't whether to use it, but how to lead alongside it.

When is the right time to switch from humans-with-AI to autonomous systems? Who's accountable when something goes wrong—the programmers, you as the leader, or the people using the program?

And here's a tricky one to consider: when do humans need to get out of the loop because AI is making better decisions than we are?

These aren't theoretical questions. Leaders are grappling with them right now.

The Next Frontier: Superhumans

What happens when AI doesn't just change what we do, but who we become?

I'm fascinated by the concept of "superhumans"—individuals who combine the best of human traits with advanced technological capabilities. These would be people with amplified humanity (deeper self-awareness, enhanced empathy, heightened emotional intelligence) combined with enhanced cognition and integrated intelligence.

Think about it: AI can help us process more information, but it can also extend our capacity for empathy when we're experiencing empathy fatigue. It can help us be more self-aware, emotionally mature, and make wiser decisions.

The workplace implications are profound:

  • Fewer barriers because we understand each other better.

  • Greater resilience because we see the impact of our work more clearly.

  • Unlocked potential as people feel more capable and take on expanded ownership.

Sounds too good to be true? Like all good things, superhumans will come with challenges of their own. They’ll push at the edges and test boundaries. They'll say, "I can do so much more now. Can I have more ownership and agency?"

Are you ready for that?

How to Lead the Superhuman Workforce

To adequately prepare for this shift, three things matter most:

  1. Design proactive HR systems for continuous evolution at the speed of your people.

  2. Model continuous learning, visibly and vulnerably. Leaders, you have to go first!

  3. Create psychological safety for debate, conflict, and experimentation.

If the only thing we're doing with AI is making organizations more efficient and productive, we're missing the point.

AI can help us be better humans and build a better society. But it will only happen if leaders like you take steps to enhance and amplify what makes us uniquely human—rather than dampening it down or leaving it at the door.

That's the biggest opportunity ahead of us.

🎤 Your Turn 

How is your leadership journey being impacted by AI? What new challenges are you facing with augmented teams or autonomous systems? I'm actively researching this and would love to hear from you.

What I Can’t Stop Talking About

  • Are your AI investments paying off? My year-end AI audit checklist helps you take stock and ensure you’re allocating time and resources to the right priorities. 

  • AI development is off the charts. Improvements are happening at a higher velocity than even a few months ago. A robust AI policy is key to safe, productive use of AI, and can improve team confidence and customer trust.

 My Upcoming Appearances/Travel

If you found this note helpful, please forward and share it with someone who needs the inspiration today. If you were forwarded this, please consider subscribing.

Join me on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and Twitter.